The Truth About Fly Tying: A Beginner’s Guide

There's something awesome about catching a fish on a fly you tied yourself. As a beginner looking to start tying flies, you've probably heard that it's a great way to save money on your fishing habit. Let me stop you right there – that myth needs debunking. Fly tying isn't about saving money; it's about something far more valuable.

The Real Economics of Fly Tying

Let's be honest: tying your flies will likely cost you more than buying them from your local fly shop. Here's what you're looking at:

- A basic vise and tool kit: $100-200

- Starter materials package: $50-100

- Individual specialized materials: $5-20 each

- Hooks and beads: $5-15 per pack

And here's the kicker – you'll probably end up with enough materials to tie 100 woolly buggers when you only needed three. Before you know it, you'll have drawers full of exotic feathers and dubbing that "might come in handy someday." 

One quick word to the wise: if your in-laws have a beagle, don’t leave hackle, fur, or feathers close to the ground. This ends poorly. 

So Why Tie Your Flies?

If not for savings, why do it? The real rewards of fly tying run much deeper:

Connection to the Sport

Every fly you tie deepens your understanding of what you're trying to imitate. You'll start noticing subtle differences in insect anatomy and behavior. This knowledge makes you a better angler, even when using store-bought flies.

Creative Satisfaction

There's a pride in fooling a trout with something you created at your desk. That first catch on a self-tied fly is a moment you'll never forget. Each successful pattern becomes a personal achievement.

Winter Therapy

Fly tying keeps your fishing passion alive during the off-season. On cold winter evenings when the streams are frozen, you can sit at your vise and prepare for spring. The repetitive, focused nature of tying can be wonderfully meditative. When I can’t get out and fish, I tie. It keeps me grounded.

Community

The fly-tying community is incredibly welcoming and supportive. Local tying groups, fly shops, and online forums are full of people eager to share techniques, patterns, and stories. You'll find mentors and make friends who share your passion.

Getting Started the Smart Way

If you're convinced that fly tying is for you, here's how to begin without breaking the bank:

1. Start with just one or two patterns you use frequently

2. Buy materials specifically for those patterns

3. Borrow or buy used tools when possible

4. Learn basic techniques before investing in expensive materials

5. Find a mentor or join a local tying group

Essential First Tools

Your essential kit should include:

- A sturdy vise (after using a cheap vise, if you want to continue tying, upgrade the vise. This doesn’t have to cost a ton, but Rambler Angler & Blade makes the Apex Vise which is a fantastic sturdy vise that will last decades on your tying station.)

- Bobbin holder

- Sharp scissors

- Hackle pliers

- Thread (size 6/0 black and white will cover most needs)

Begin with the Basics

Focus on fundamental patterns like:

- Woolly Bugger

- Pheasant Tail Nymph

- Elk Hair Caddis

These patterns teach essential techniques that transfer to more complex flies.

The Path Forward

Like fly fishing itself, tying is a journey of continuous learning. You'll make mistakes, waste materials, and tie some ugly flies at first. But with practice, patience, and persistence, you'll develop skills that enhance your fishing experience.

Fly tying isn't about saving money – it's about enriching your connection to the sport, expressing creativity, and joining a community of passionate crafters - and, in some cases, artists. The satisfaction of catching a fish on your own fly is worth far more than any money you might save buying commercially tied patterns.

---

*Ready to start your fly-tying journey? Follow @oldlineangling on Instagram and stand by for a new fly-tying series for beginners! You should always consider visiting your local fly shop, where you'll find materials and tools, valuable advice, and perhaps even tying classes to get you started on the right foot.*